1115 Comments
User's avatar
Anthony's avatar

I loved this article. I see at my university with terms like Latinx. As a Mexican American I see that young kids from privileged backgrounds are exploiting all this bs. Everyone wants to be a victim and everyone is so easily offended and scared of self reflection and criticism.

VanishingTribe's avatar

". . . young kids from privileged backgrounds are exploiting all this bs."

Read Ted Kaczynski. He predicted exactly this and much more.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

That doesn't make him murdering innocent people the correct conclusion for dealing with that analysis.

Oregoncharles's avatar

Yeah, that's why he was clearly insane, if perceptive - shocking how often they go together.

Kelly Green's avatar

I recall very vividly watching a CNN town hall panel of average citizens talking about the Trayvon Martin case. One young woman wanted to say something very important to her: "And why did you say I'm African-American?" she asked the panel moderator. "I think that's ridiculous. Charlize Theron is African-American. I'm *Black*." She was a liberal, proud, black woman speaking her mind and it was beautiful. There is a pretty big distance between the average minority voter and the progressive leftist that wants to use terms like African-American and Latinx.

Kelly Green's avatar

BTW, the most ridiculous part of this is that "retard" is no longer acceptable. Kids in middle school are already calling people they want to insult "mentally disabled"... "What, do you have a mental disability or something?". Remember "Idiot" was a clinical term that turned into an insult and so they changed the clinical term to "mentally retarded" which turned into an insult and so they changed the clinical term.... it's a neverending cycle. The American Kennel Club has been wise enough to continue using bitch, because as soon as they change it, it will be co-opted for use as an insult.

Tytonidaen's avatar

The phenomenon is often referred to as the "euphemism treadmill".

Carol Jones's avatar

Exactly--it is truly the victim mentality-- it is all about finding a special tribe-- being special by being able to say things from a protected place. So tiresome if it wasn't so sad and pathetic. What kind of values do these people have.

Phisto Sobanii's avatar

The ones given to them, most likely. We're a consumerist culture that's commodified everything, including ourselves. It's no wonder we desperately want to be in boxes.

Takes a while to deprogram, you know?

I ain't old, but I ain't young anymore, and it's only recently that I've come around to the idea of rejecting labels entirely. There's a few I'll accept for myself, but only as shorthand descriptions. I'll use them to describe others too, but again for the same purpose.

People are deep. You can't ever slap a word on 'em and call the job done.

Lightwing's avatar

“Behavior is truth.” —Andrew Vachss

Art's avatar

"People are deep. You can't ever slap a word on 'em and call the job done."

Mostly, perhaps, but I can definitely cite a few examples. Or, if there's anything more deep in them, their ugly natures tend to overwhelm any interest in finding it; we have to judge people by what they express to us. And while beauty may only be skin deep, ugly is often to the bone, and I don't mean that literally.

Art's avatar

oops, I meant counter-examples! Obviously! (Where's that edit button when you need it?!)

Jim M's avatar

I'm Irish. Born in NYC to immigrant parents. Who would get truly pissed off if someone mistook them for Welsh, Scot, or god forbid English (my grandfather fought in the Easter Rebellion). Here's my question:

Isn't 'Latinex' kind of racist in itself? I mean...lumping in a Cuban with a Peruvian or Mexican? My personal experience of both VZ & Cuba demonstrates two cultures as distinct as the Irish and the Scots. I dunno...

Ibbiat's avatar

I don't think latinx is racist for that reason... in my experience, latin people are happy to call themselves latino or latina in their native Spanish. Latino/latina is a common word in Spanish (it's the same word, just gender-inflected) and people use it frequently.

The problem to me is that 'latinx' seems to be a Spanish word that was coopted by non-Spanish speakers to nonsensically remove the gender inflection.

Every noun in Spanish is gender-inflected. If you tell a Spanish speaker to speak without gender inflection, you might as well tell them to not talk. There is no means in the language to remove the gender inflection of a word. To even attempt to do so is approaching the problem from a state of complete ignorance, as I understand things. How embarrassing.

Anthony's avatar

Latinx wherever it came from didn’t come from a Hispanic person. That term was forced upon people by some intellectual at a University to pretend that normal people give a shit about that term.

Things weren’t easy growing up where I did but I overcame that and didn’t blame everyone and their Mother for things being rough. I’ve struggled less in school than others because I have had to deal with real problems. I’ve had classes complain about reading too much in a Masters program. These kids are coddled now and you see that in all aspects of life but media is a prime example and the elite media are the same people running the universities and educational systems

Sevender's avatar

If Latinx can be used as a noun what do you call a good Latinx? A Latinx buenx?

Pawsative's avatar

Since ‘Latin’ worked just fine there was no reason to create ‘Latino’ other than wanting to queer the word.

Pawsative's avatar

‘Latinx’ not ‘Latino’

Phisto Sobanii's avatar

Thank you for explaining that. And by gods is it stupid. Haha!

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 7, 2021
Comment deleted
Ibbiat's avatar

"Hey, we made a new word for your nationality/ethnicity/heritage that's inoffensive. Oh, and also, there's literally no way you can say this word in your own language and have it be grammatically correct. You're welcome."

Cathy Carron's avatar

Polls show that most Latinos don’t like latinx

Art's avatar

What about the oppressed of that cultur, the Latinas?

D. Malcolm Carson's avatar

. . . putting aside the fact that somewhere around 2-3% of those who are presumably described by it actually identify with "Latinx" versus "Latino" or better yet "Hispanic".

Jim M's avatar

I'm sorry, but I don't know what you're trying to say. Could you expand on this?

D. Malcolm Carson's avatar

You're correct that "lumping in" dozens of different ethnic groups under the general term "Latinx" (never seen it written with an "e") is itself kind of racist, or at least reductive of the complexity of those groups. However, there's another insult involved which is calling people something that they themselves do not wish to be called. Pew did a study and found that it's rarely the preferred term: https://www.pewresearch.org/hispanic/2020/08/11/about-one-in-four-u-s-hispanics-have-heard-of-latinx-but-just-3-use-it/

George Steffner's avatar

I guess many want unique identity but all the British Islanders were people of the Celtic nation originally. True nations are related people, not the false substitution word for a bordered country.

My culture was prominently Scots-Irish until the 1950s when various hordes flooded out of Philadelphia all over them. Ironically Scots-Irish refugee hordes from the battle with the Church of England's domination over their Presbytery had flooded the original Quakers and Mennonites in Pennsylvania. Much Larger hordes of starving overpopulated, (no) thanks to a South American potato, Irish came soon after and hordes from also overpopulated Europe followed them.

No cultures want to be dominated by others even if there is enough land confiscated from other species to share. We see that still today, often stupidly hidden behind phony race/ethnicity covers when the real battle is between incompatible cultures.

The Irish, the Scots, and the Welsh were all Celtic groups until the Germanic hordes, Vikings (Norwegians in Ireland, Danes in Scotland and England) and Germans (Angles and Saxons in southern Britain), began invading/migrating into those isles. The Germanic and Celtic nations, including the mostly Celtic French, are very different cultures from each other but both are similar within their own nations.

Under the stress of ever more overpopulation true nations battle for land and resources with each other, or groups within nations will if the need is more immediate. Scott and Irish clans battled incessantly centuries ago, as did Japanese clans, some battles historically notorious. Ironically Picts held northern Britain until Irish "Scotty" invaded. If they hadn't it would now be "Pictland."

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

Exactly, people are so afraid to admit they are white they are pretending to be spanish like Hillary Baldwin.

North Country's avatar

Well, I think Hillaria is faking Spanish heritage for attention, money, and because she’s not right in the head.

Sonja's avatar

Why not Comedia? That was my only question. Comedia is more international.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 7, 2021
Comment deleted
Pawsative's avatar

That’s because identity politics replaces a hierarchy of meritocracy with a hierarchy of victimhood. Just like the communists elevated the poorest peasant and street criminals above all others - even within the gulags. Everyone ends up fighting with each other and jockeying for favor while the elite goes about systematically killing off and persecuting the smarter ones who could pose a threat to the elites’ power. Ultimately Marxism/Commumism is about nihilism a killing humans but first in order to do this, they must destroy humanity and the institutions that hold society together / civilization. It takes a murderous psychopath to think and do what communists / marxists / identity politics do. Their goal is a ihli sting the human race. Of course that hint about this with things like the climate change agenda and population control and dissuading women from having children - especially the smart ones who would have smarty children.

Pete Needham's avatar

You describe capitalists perfectly.

Jeff's avatar

I wish I could remember where I read it so i could provide a link, but I recall a survey that found that only about 3% of those of Hispanic heritage approved of the latinx label.

Lightwing's avatar

And one of the saddest consequences of this trend is that a great many actual victims become invisible because "poser victims" are hogging the limelight.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 9, 2021
Comment deleted
Lightwing's avatar

Say it in Dana Carvey's "Church Lady" voice. ;-)

BradK (Tuckered out)'s avatar

I only with Glenn would stop using the term liberal to describe these cretins. There is only one descriptor which applies: Marxist.

Nenad Lovric's avatar

Actual Marxists are class-based economic populists. They don’t give a shit about stuff like this. Maybe you mean “Stalinist”, which is more applicable. These people are basically authoritarians, that’s about it, and authoritarianism can come from the right just as it can come from the center or the left.

Scuba Cat's avatar

It strikes me as more Mao-ist, in that it attacks a person's essential character.

Alicia's avatar

Chinese cultural evolution struggle sessions. Turn in your family and friends for "wrong think."

Pawsative's avatar

All communists have done that. That’s how witch hunts work.

Alicia's avatar

Sorry is should be Chinese cultural revolution.

Pete Needham's avatar

🎶If mommy is a commie, boys, you gotta turn her in...”🎶

-excerpt from “John Birch Society” song by The Chad Mitchell Trio.

Nenad Lovric's avatar

Agreed, that term works pretty well here too.

Commentorinchief's avatar

What is the point of people always making this relativist point that evil can come from all sides of the political spectrum? Who cares? It is coming from the Left now. That is what matters. If we don’t stop it NOW we won’t be around to watch out for it next time.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

I'm pretty hardcore conservative anti-government but you'd struggle to convince me only the left is evil. People like Newt Gingrich and Liz Cheney or Mitt Romney all represent that same lockstep-party elitism (within the own elite of their party at that) and are just as happy to bomb someone they dislike. They would do whatever is asked of them like good little bootlickers if it meant furthering their and "the parties" ideals.

Commentorinchief's avatar

I agree 100%. They are all evil. But it isn’t RINO’s acting like the Misleadia Gestapo is it?

Pawsative's avatar

Romney and Chaney are the uni-party establishment. They are neo-cons and are not conservatives.

Nenad Lovric's avatar

I made that point because I think it matters in terms of credibility and consistency: that we should oppose authoritarianism as a matter of principle, whether it’s coming from the left, center or right. So that cynics can’t come at you with “Oh you’re only against it now because it’s coming from the left/right, but you were/would be just fine with it when/if it was coming from YOUR side”. That’s all I meant by it.

Commentorinchief's avatar

That’s fair. Thanks for the explanation. My fear is there won’t be a next time, at least not here in our lifetime. At least that is what history teaches us.

Art's avatar

"It is coming from the Left now."

False. You right-wingers don't seem to know a damned thing about what's actually left.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

There is definitely evil coming from the left now, its unfortunate you fail to see it. Are you someone who approves of McCarthyism and intolerance?

Phisto Sobanii's avatar

Good and evil are for stories you tell to children at bedtime. This is plain old power politics, same as it's always been. Just mixed up in a different way thanks to technology like the internet, social decay, and a dramatically different world order since the end of the Cold War.

You can't stop it. No point in it. However, you can make like Hawkeye Pierce and get as many of the victims out as you can before you're done.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

It does seem to me that we Americans do need our archetypes of both good and evil. Its so odd too that there has to be a person symbolizing it.

VioletEM's avatar

I don't like saying this because it bolsters bad memes but you should google the frankfurt school. basically this tripe has direct lineal ties to marxism.

martin's avatar

strange that we have to google the frankfurt school and were never taught about it.

Nenad Lovric's avatar

Oh ok, thanks. I’m sure there have been many different strains of Marxism since the time his major works were published, so you may be right. I guess I tend to think of Marxism primarily in terms of Marx’s original analyses of capitalism as expressed in his own work.

Sevender's avatar

There are certainly ties to French deconstructionist oddities as well. But this language is mostly used by decrepit Reaganites to attack economic leftism.

Hasan's avatar

There is no need to put a foreign boogeyman on this. This behavior of entitlement and trying to destroy others is very American. These journalists aren’t just liberals) conservatives also have the same pathos. All of them are typically American (or British). This is the fundamental holier than thou mentality of Americans.

Art's avatar

"These journalists" are neo-liberals.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

Is Marxism really populism? What about when we automate all the rote tasks on earth? What will be left for the workers of the world to unite behind if there is no work?

BradK (Tuckered out)'s avatar

Marxism is sold to the gullible masses as economic populism through the politics of envy -- power to the people -- but that's only the brochure. In reality Marxism and its offshoots are only ever implemented through the iron fist of absolute authoritarianism. The "equality" promised to the proles is one of shared misery while the oligarchs enjoy the spoils of their labors. Thank you, COVID-19.

Capitalism is far from perfect but at least it offers opportunity to advance if you work for it. To wit: Dolly Parton's redux of 9 to 5 as 5 to 9 and the bitter NBC (National Bullshit Corp.) reaction to it. Nothing comes for free, no matter what they promise.

Geoff's avatar

Once you have an -ism, you have people in charge. The type of people who jockey to be in charge are rarely the sort who should. The greatest miracle since Christ's resurrection was George Washington voluntarily stepping down. But now that power is centralized in the bureaucracy, there's a new way to be in charge. Capitalism and Communism share the same fatal flaw: Whatever they purport to stand for, their end result is the creation of power centers where organizational maneuvering and favor trading to maintain the status quo replaces the original mission because human beings are fallible and concentration of power leads to concentrated corruption.

George Steffner's avatar

They are "democratic," at least they think they are until they face opposition. Then they become pseudo-Marxists. They demand their "best of all" ideals (non-functional in this non-ideal world) be rammed into it.

Janine's avatar

Maoist. A couple of BLM founders from Berkeley also were associated with old tie Mao organizer from way back. That's why it all resembles cultural revolution inanity

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 7, 2021
Comment deleted
Deanna's avatar

Agreed! I fear it is going to get worse before it gets better.

Jen Koenig's avatar

My fear is people just not seeing it. I work in tech (UX Designer) and have lived on the coasts until I escaped with my family into the "dreaded" interior. All of my ex-agency friends and upper middle class Seattle and Austin friends think all of this is just fine. These policies don't affect them and they're convinced Trump was literally Hitler and anything, even election rigging, is legitimate in stopping this. They really seem to believe that we need multinational corporations, Wall Street and the CIA to protect us from half the country who are literally the KKK. They all were tweeting in unison "Vote like your life depends on it. Because it does!" They literally believe Covid stopped the minute Biden was elected and now were are finally free from tyranny. They're.. crazy? I've never seen such moral hysteria. Ultimately, this cannot hold. Rule by elites can be tolerated when the elites are competant and most citizens are reasonably happy, but these elites are in a crazy bubble and some of the most incompetent leaders around. I keep telling myself this HAS to cave in at some point, but when? Its like there's two realities at play here. It's not a right / left thing anymore. It's...I can't explain this. I really can't.

Oregoncharles's avatar

It's how former democracies decay and die.

Diogenes's avatar

I think our current time approximates America during WW1. I don't think it's a mistake Espionage Act of 1917 is coming back into style.

The key difference is that you needed an actual war to get the people to turn on The Bill of Rights in 1917. We're now so afraid of our own shadow that a handful of yahoos taking selfies for Facebook at the capital is enough for most people to eagerly beg those in power to take away their rights.

Pawsative's avatar

It’s the Chinese model which combines them all but McCarthy had noting on the reign of terror of the Communists - neither did the Spanish Inquisition. It Definitely is not ‘right’. Fascism is leftist. All communists regimes are tyrannical.

Pete Needham's avatar

The KKK agrees with you that blacks are the real racists.

Patrick McAuliffe's avatar

In a way it seems like the germination of an historically illiterate theocracy, and these journalists are positioning themselves to be the Jesuits of a new ruling class.

Sonja's avatar

Very nicely stated. But above all, these highly competent neolibs are jockeying for position not by improving themselves and their work (hard), but by slaying the competition (ridiculously easy). That's what is really behind all of these machinations.

When everyone does it, mistakes like this one will be forgiven. After all, not to forgive might bring a demand for higher standards on all their heads. YEESH. Anything but that.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

Its vertically integrated business, politics, and media, on a global level. Its arguably the worst thing that could ever happen to "the people". The reason the global economy doesn't work correctly is because people and countries are different and markedly different economies. What happens when you rage low-end wages in the US? Ask the Steel industry. Ask the auto-manufacturing industry. The work goes to other countries for less cost and better ROI for the very investors the big companies work for.

George Steffner's avatar

You have been buying other left propaganda about their fascist cousins. They lie about fascist "corporatization" and pretend it's "corporatism." It's not.

Fascism is dictatorial (usually nation) socialism. All major entities are put under public (not private as lying other left propagandists pretend) corporate structure. The fascist state confiscates the majority of (owned in common) stock so it controls all major industries just as other socialist governments do.

The fascist state demands everyone work for the good of the society in general as all other socialist governments expect.

Ehsan Qadir's avatar

"But it's also fascist, in that government is openly colluding with corporate powers to control narratives and silence dissent." -- That is why people call these wokes the 'neo-fascists' or crypto-fascists.

Char's avatar

Nenad, It sounds crazy putting all those together--but that stew sounds damned accurate! I don't know about authoritarianism coming from the center- it's usually born out of the extreme fringes- right or left. But when we take the center of the line and move right and left--the extremes bend the curve and actually meet--both equally scary!

George Steffner's avatar

Fascist collusions with corporations are lies from other socialists. The socialist frauds perpetrating those lies perpetually try to divorce their fascist socialist cousins. Fascism prescribes "corporatizing" (not "corporatism" as the their ordinary democratic socialist cousins pretend) where everything, all industries and agencies, is put under "public" corporate structure (socialist "owned in common [stock]") with the "state" holding a majority of stock in all the public (only, no private "capitalist") major corporations. That gave the fascist "state" control over all major industries and agencies.

NSDAP, in 1930s-1940s Germany, allowed petite bourgeoisie ("sole proprietor" shop keepers and tradesmen) to own their businesses and run them as they wished, but all major industries were ordered to "work for the good of the [German] nation" and all military industries were to be nationalized.

https://www.vaholocaust.org/25-points-of-nsdap/

Art's avatar

-chuckle-

That's one of the most ridiculous comments I've yet read regarding fascism. For one thing, this is truly laughable:

"Fascist collusions with corporations are lies from other socialists."

That sentence illustrates a failure to understand what fascism even is.

Fascism is the merger of state and business power, however achieved. How you can reconcile the quoted sentence with reality is a real mystery.

Jim Trageser's avatar

Meh, it's broader than just Marxism or leftist - I mean, the fascists employed domestic spies to ferret out opposition, too. Totalitarianism seems the word that most accurately describes their behavior: We have the right to control what you can say, and by exercising it over time, to control what you allow yourself to think.

Ryband's avatar

Totalitarianism IS the closest descriptor. Throughout the 20th century both the “left” and the “right” employed this form of social control.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

So different and yet so alike in their possession of power.

Phisto Sobanii's avatar

Power is power. Ideology is just the flavoring.

Like Kool-Aid, amusingly.

SW's avatar

Welcome to East Berlin.

Pawsative's avatar

Fascism is leftist. Just look at communist China.

Art's avatar

ANOTHER knee-slapper!

"Fascism is leftist."

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAhahahaha! WOW! That's just so damned clueless.

Fascism is the merger of state and business power and you don't get any more "right wing" than that.

Pawsative's avatar

Tell China that. And the NAZIs did the same thing.

Neil Kellen's avatar

Fascism and tyranny ALWAYS come from the left. Always.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 7, 2021
Comment deleted
JRobie's avatar

Woke Ayatollahs, yes! That works.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 7, 2021
Comment deleted
Alicia's avatar

Narcissists use negative emotions to dominate and control people. When they say "speech is violence" they mean that the negative emotions they experience and the harm they do to their own health are caused by people not letting them control them. The statement "intention is irrelevant" is basically a narcissistic power grab.

memento mori's avatar

Well Senator Joseph McCarthy and his ilk used essentially the same tactics and I would hardly have called them Marxists.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

Do you feel anything was different from what McCarthy did and what the DNC and McCain did to Trump in 2016?

Pawsative's avatar

McCarthy was a piker.

Pawsative's avatar

Psychopaths. Narcissistic nihilistic psychopaths.

Phisto Sobanii's avatar

I have a suggestion.

They're cunts.

Sevender's avatar

The hilarity of neoliberals realizing they have turned their reputations to shit now wanting to blame Marxists.

Bert Powers's avatar

Liberals are champions of free speech and always have been. These control freak snitches don't deserve that noble title.

Alex DeLarge's avatar

"Liberal" is definitely wrong and should go away. "Progressive" is better but it risks lumping in those leftists who are intellectually honest.

"Marxist" won't catch on, and doesn't really fit anyway. These creepy authoritarians are actually all for Capitalism, but only in the form crony-capitalism and woke-capitalism.

We definitely need a new, more accurate label for the philosophy espoused by the NYT. Which is basically a toxic brew of elitism, crony corporatism, anti-white racism, and censorship.

Geoff's avatar

I think a fundamental problem is that both parties are vehicles for crony capitalists to print money and pillage the economy. The only argument is about which rich people should get the plunder and whose minions should get the power.

Oregoncharles's avatar

Huh? What does Marx have to do with it? It's authoritarian, which some Marxists (and a lot of fascists) are; as well as, variously, petty, self-aggrandizing, and so on. It's very sad to see such attitudes associated with "liberal," but here we are.

Pawsative's avatar

Marxists aren’t liberal.

Alan Hodgson's avatar

No, but modern american liberals are certainly trying to be Marxists.

Sonja's avatar

"Marxist?" Sounds more like this Taylor Lorenz person was born too late and missed her true calling as a COINTELPRO operative. No marginally rational or ethical person would sign up for what she's pushing. Who is teaching people to call it "Marxist?" How did they persuade you?

Art's avatar

Indeed. ... It appears poor Brad here doesn't even know what Marxism is...

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

I really wish some of you posters would stop trying to be the gatekeepers of who is "left" or "right" and who is "liberal" and who is "conservative". I have yet to see a poster make a comment I agree with regarding who is left or right. We all have a different view of that because we all represent a different political position. People that peacock left-wing ideals and constantly attack right wing conservative positions are either independents or liberals. Since none of the people mentioned are independents, walk me through why you don't think they are "liberal". Are you suggesting they are conservatives?

Art's avatar

"We all have a different view of that because we all represent a different political position."

No, a lot of us have "a different view of that" because of propaganda, and different groups are propagandized a bit differently than other groups.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

I 100% represent a different political position than you. I'd bet you $100 any poster on this forum disagrees with you on some piece of policy. The two party system wants everyone to fit into this nice little mold, but the facts are no one does.

George Steffner's avatar

Actually Marxists (advocating forced infusion of international communism) are rare here. Most left was progressive (advocating protections for workers and consumers) but today they are moving farther left to socialism (industries owned in common and/or controlled by government) with some ordinary (not necessarily Marxist) communist policies (wealth distribution according to need).

George Steffner's avatar

They aren't actually Marxists. They are "democratic," at least they think they are until they face opposition. Then they become pseudo-Marxists. They demand their "best of all" ideals (non-functional in this non-ideal world) be rammed into it. Of course it always becomes a disaster because most people are not ideal people for them, except a rare few like the communal for millennia Norse and ultra-disciplined Japanese.

UrsaMinor's avatar

I'm sure you meant fascists.

Benn Redward's avatar

What exactly about these liberals makes you think they want workers to take control of the means of production??

martin's avatar

what about 'christian'? i vaguely remember them engaging in this kind of censorship.

Oregoncharles's avatar

"Super-Christian." Above reference to the Inquisition and Witch Hunts fits, minus burning at the stake - so far.

Phased's avatar

How do we fight this nonsense? It doesn’t matter that they’re wrong or blatantly lying. They put the narrative out then it’s blasted out everywhere and public opinion is formed. Then they just walk away. Zero consequences for them. It’s entirely absurd.

Chauncey Gardiner's avatar

Good question; something we all wonder about.

The only I could offer so far might be to refer to Vaclac Havel's essay "The Power of the Powerless". One thing I get out of that essay is that when a critical mass of people know that the system is a joke, and everyone in that critical mass knows that a critical mass of people know it's a joke, then the system becomes likely to collapse under its own weight. So, what to do?: Keep talking. Keep reading. Keep honing one's language for discussing these things. Keep cataloguing examples of indefensible things that one can roll out. There's nothing like colorful examples to make a point.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

Its typical for our entire country across the board. The rule of "law" is a joke that really means the rule of the "elite". This is why Epstein's deal was "at the highest levels of Justice" and Cheryl Mills got an immunity deal even though Hillary and them "did nothing wrong". The only thing that defeats lawyers is guns. This is why the DNC is so fucking shook by the Capitol uprising.

Carol Jones's avatar

"Lawyers guns and money"-- the best Warren Zevon song-- an ode to Hunter Thompson

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

The shit has hit the fan :) :)

Jim Reynolds's avatar

Zero consequences for them? They get paid very well for however knowingly or unknowingly serving the propaganda agenda of the masters of the world.

Very probably unknowingly. Look inside, we are all hypocritical in one way or another. We can rationalize or justify a great deal when we receive some kind of reward for thinking or behaving this way or that.

Vent outrage to people who will truly listen and strive to understand, if that’s what we need to do.

Talk with people we know with a genuine desire to sympathetically understand what they think and why. This is perhaps the greatest challenge, and takes a lot to cultivate.

When people feel cared about, heard, taken seriously, they are much more likely to consider alternative perspectives.

There are only a small minority who consciously and malevolently pursue thoroughly anti-social agendas. We need to be with as many of the rest as we can be, and we need them with us.

It really (significant change) does happen one person, one act, at a time, forming associations.

Talk with someone who’s hard to talk to, if we want to push harder! It’s agonizingly slow. On the other hand, big positive changes can happen fast.

Have hope and do something achievable and strategic. As Chomsky says, What’s the other choice?

Carol Jones's avatar

Don't feed the trolls--point them out but don't feed them. Feeding them gives them power and influence.

Phisto Sobanii's avatar

Find places both online and off where you can say exactly what you want and discuss whatever you feel like without consequences. However that needs to happen.

Think it through. Make sure these pukes can't do shit. When they try?

Laugh and laugh and laaaaaaugh.

judd's avatar

Laugh at them if you can't engage compassionately. Also, find your people, discover your purpose. If you fight fire with fire you just get burned...let them perish...

Melissa Maggioncalda's avatar

Ignore these punks and Speak with your money! Don't click on nor subscribe to NYT, Washington Post, etc. What goes around comes around and these morons will pay dearly. These folks are not journalists and we should not treat them as such.

Scuba Cat's avatar

Morons used to be a clinical term. Can you be cancelled for that?

Jim M's avatar

So was 'mentally retarded'. Just sayin'

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 7, 2021
Comment deleted
Jim M's avatar

And if I hurt your feelings, in the words of (I think) Christopher Hitchens, 'what's your point?' LOL (I love that guy; RIP)

Carol Jones's avatar

"Way ahead of you" (quoting Brad Pitt in "Once upon a time in Hollywood"- one of Tarantinos best)

Jim M's avatar

Been hacking WaPo for years now and am cancelling the NYT for the last time today.

Mark Mezzina's avatar

This guy has absolutely no clue how to take a week off, and I love it. Keep up the great work Glenn.

Jim M's avatar

And that concerns me...

Andrew's avatar

Thanks for another well written article. That Chase Strangio would call out JK Rowling as being "aligned with white supremacists" doesn't surprise me. The goal posts of "white supremacy" has changed from literal nazis, KKK members, and devout racists, to every white person that doesn't virtue signal in the appropriate way. The corporate media and their enablers are just gaslighting everyone into submission.

VanishingTribe's avatar

"The corporate media and their enablers are just gaslighting everyone into submission."

Not everyone. ;)

Lightwing's avatar

Wish I could like this x 1000.

Beeswax's avatar

And don’t forget Abigail Shrier, who’s Jewish. I’m sure she enjoyed being called a white supremacist.

norstadt's avatar

You don't have to be white to be accused of "white supremacy culture". The "culture" bit is supposed to soften the term. Look up Kenneth Salim (who is very pro-minority and not white) in the Boston Globe from Jan. 25.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

We see now that many on the left are just as happy to silence dissenting opinion as the very people on the right that they "fought against".

Lightwing's avatar

Ironic, no? I sometimes feel like my life is an episode of the twilight zone. When I was young, I was trying to avoid Republicans and Christians (the evangelical types). Now, I am trying to steer clear of self-righteous Dems and the regressive left. Never dreamed it would turn out this way. Reminds me of a song:

"Clowns to the left of me, jokers to the right. Here I am, stuck in the middle with you." —Stealers Wheel

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 7, 2021
Comment deleted
Phisto Sobanii's avatar

"You're a Nazi, Harry!"

lol

David Pare's avatar

These "reporters" are really starting to look desperate. With the Bad Orange Man gone, what will they write about? You can't write fawningly every single day about Kamala's shoes. If it were me, I'd start asking about why that Federal Minimum Wage of $15 vanished from the Stimulus Bill. But that would take guts, and I don't think they have any.

Rfhirsch's avatar

The $15 minimum wage was taken out of the bill because enough members of Congress realized the terrible impact it would have on minorities. Roughly 2 million jobs would be lost, and the share of blacks and Hispanics losing jobs would be much higher than their portion of the population. Every economist from Thomas Sowell on down has said that minimum wages have a bad impact, especially on minorities and young people looking for a first job. Plus, a minimum wage of $15 may have less impact in expensive areas, but it would have a disastrous impact on jobs in areas with normal prices.

Katisha's avatar

Is the Seattle area foundering due to a high minimum wage? No it isn't. And. My mother was in the multicultural movement fighting for Living Wage in the 80s and 90s in L.A. so I know about the economics. If you get higher pay, then you can afford to pay more for your burger.

Want to stay in a hotel in Tucson or Phoenix? Over $100 a night for a decent room.

Yet hospitality workers in AZ are getting paid peanuts. Get real. We're already living in an oligarchy. We need higher wages for the working class!

Political Economist's avatar

It may come as a surprise to you that the entire country is not the same as Seattle.

Katisha's avatar

Yup. And why I mentioned Tucson. How'd you miss that? I've lived in 8 states, and now live in the poorest state in the US. While growing up, my single parent had to use food stamps. I've worked as a cleaner.

And your bona fides? Looking at your handle, I doubt you have any actual knowledge of the working class.

Beep Boop's avatar

Wasted breath, surely, but nevertheless:

"The city’s escalating minimum wage has meant a slight increase in pay among workers earning up to $19 per hour, but the hours worked in such jobs have shrunk, a study commissioned by the city found. It estimates there would be 5,000 more such jobs without the Seattle law."

And due to reductions in overall hours: "For an average low-wage worker in Seattle, that translates into a loss of about $125 per month per job."

https://www.seattletimes.com/business/uw-study-finds-seattles-minimum-wage-is-costing-jobs/

Art's avatar

"Every economist from Thomas Sowell on down has said that minimum wages have a bad impact," is a jack-booted propagandist for the ultra-rich. They're completely full of shit.

As for "normal prices", that's its own joke. Unfortunately, I don't really have the energy for that dialogue right now - maybe we can talk about it intelligently some other time, but the short-short-short of it is that keeping the min-wage down suppresses natural price increases that actually help EVERYONE on Main Street because it puts more money in circulation on Main Street.

Russel's avatar

Looks like developed nations without minimum wages rely on trade unions to set wages, such as Sweden. It would be interesting to look into the intricacies of this system.

Art's avatar

That certainly helps! They also have solidarity among their unions.

James's avatar

Thomas Sowell - a Milton Friedman senior shill at the right-wing neoliberal Hoover Institute? What does Rfhirsch mean by "Sowell on down" mean in this case? Does it mean other paid shills of the establishment who never stopped to reflect that the absurd assumptions of their macro-economic models reflect an imaginary world with no connection to reality?

David Pare's avatar

Interesting. So if they all knew about this effect, why did the Administration put it in there in the first place? To give false hope to all those $7.50/hour workers? Was it just a con all along? Kind of a big deal to those workers; I read there were 40 million people making < $15/hour.

Rfhirsch's avatar

Well there are many politicians who see the minimum wage as a way to get support from voters, even if it affects those voters negatively after it is raised. And not that many politicians understand economics or even want to. The number of such workers is not that large.

David Pare's avatar

I think this is where I read it: 42.4 million people made < $15/hour back in 2016. The information is a bit old. Do you have newer information? https://slate.com/business/2016/03/how-many-workers-earn-less-than-15-per-hour.html

Pawsative's avatar

It’s was vote buying. They rallied the loser left in to riots to do their bidding to scare the judiciary, politicians and public so they could make their power grab. They got it and now it’s back to business as usual. White liberals and black rednecks screwing over everyone else. Fleecing the taxpayers and abusing power.

Diogenes's avatar

So you are saying that politicians opposed an increase in the minimum wage based on........checks notes........concern for it's impact on minorities.

Whether increasing the minimum is a good idea (which I think it is) is a separate debate, but the idea a politician did anything because in their heart of hearts they worried some policy would negatively impact minorities is to fundamentally misunderstand what a morally vacuous sociopath a politicians is.

When you provide me with the most cynical, self serving reason for anything they do, I will believe you.

Politicians are there to serve the powerful. Anything else is simply

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 7, 2021
Comment deleted
D. Malcolm Carson's avatar

Sowell is not an Uncle Tom; he's one of the foremost philosophers of our time, and he cares deeply about the fate of black people in America. An "Uncle Tom" is a black person who sells out their own people in order to enjoy the privileges of acceptance in white society. Sowell's black critics are far more accepted by white society at universities, in the media and in government than he is, it's not remotely close. His prescriptions for what ails black people have proven far more effective than whatever it is that his critics are selling, just look at the status of black people in any "blue" area of the country. He doesn't blame "shiftless black folk" for the ills of the country, he blames clueless white liberals!

Pawsative's avatar

White liberals and Black Rednecks

Pete Needham's avatar

Ahh...you have all of Sowell’s pamphlets!

SimulationCommander's avatar

I love how you ignore the original purpose of the min wage: Keeping minorities out of the job market.

It's still working.

Russel's avatar

Policies will always have unintended side effects, it’s certainly possible that this is one of them. Where do you get the idea it was done on purpose though?

We needs to ask what the benefits as well as negatives are. Then weigh their value against facts rather than ideologies.

Apollo's Lyre's avatar

Debates about the efficacy of the minimum wage and the notion of bailing out Wall Street certainly have their merits; however, the offhanded dismissal of Thomas Sowell's illustrious career with a derisive epithet has no merit whatsoever.

Alicia's avatar

Your comment is typical of the narcissistic rage of regressive left activists when they come across opinions they do not like. This is the same set of emotions behind the cancel culture that this article is about.

If there is systemic racism in the US holding back blacks, why does the latest census data show Nigerian households in the US making more than white households? Also, there are now six nonwhite ethnic groups that earn more than white households. My partner got a Lyft ride home from an immigrant from Africa. He explained that he works full time as an engineer, but works weekends as a Lyft driver to save up the down payment for a house. For many immigrants, the US is the least racists, most free and prosperous country that has ever existed.

Sowell's point about the minimum wage is that few people stay at that low level of pay for very long. The lower wage makes it easier for businesses to create entry-level jobs for unskilled workers. The workers gain job skills as they work, and move on to higher paying jobs.

Wazoomann's avatar

Mmm...Uncle Tom. Dude. I don't agree with the, "let capitalism sort them out play", but Uncle Tom? That over the top language immediately "cancels" your argument. People stop listening. Anyone that might have "gotten" your point, even agreed with it, are lost.

Boatguy's avatar

Wow, Uncle Tom Is even more caustic and vile than retarded, is in contempt of the essay and in reality the comment itself is seriously mentally deficient.

Katisha's avatar

Sowell isn't an Uncle T, he's a Reaganite neolib like millions of Americans of every race. Maybe we should applaud his ability to step on the downtrodden poor like all these other arseholes. The trait most Americans share is kicking away the ladder as soon as they make it to the top.

Pel's avatar

Stepping on the downtrodden poors, kicking away the ladder as soon as one made it to the top -- these actions and human character features are truly terrible... only they belong not to Thomas Sowell but to the shameless liars who take to convince those downtrodden poors that there is anything for them in minimum wage laws other than perpetuation and worsening of their conditions.

Deco's avatar

Please tell me your profile photo is parody, because I need to stop laughing.

Political Economist's avatar

Why don't you detail a few of those "many ways?"

I'm looking forward to this.

Russel's avatar

Never really understood the all or nothing mentality of conservatives and liberals in regards to this issue. It seems to me both racism and culture are contributing factors.

ChesterView's avatar

John, just curious. What is your current occupation and your educational background?

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 7, 2021
Comment deleted
libertate's avatar

I would wager that not a single one of these leftist morons disparaging Dr. Sowell has read even one of his many books, or much of anything else of merit for that matter.

This rocket scientist Orban is the progressive-moron poster boy. He doesn't realize that Malcom X was talking about HIM is his 1963 speech about white liberals.

He doesn't know that the origin of the minimum wage in the U.S. was to protect white northern union labor from being undercut by southern blacks.

He doesn't know that minimum wages were used in apartheid South Africa to protect white wages against black competition.

In short, like most leftists, he doesn't know much of anything about anything. But despite his profound ignorance, he nevertheless feels entitled to call Dr. Sowell, who fought his way out of abject poverty to become among the leading economist on the planet, and "Uncle Tom".

Dr. Sowell knew more about economics and reality at 10 years old than this Orban fuckwit will ever know.

Cathy Carron's avatar

‘Free speech’ does bring out the a—holes : ) Thomas Sowell is a national treasure

Russel's avatar

I agree, it’s always better to know how people really feel

Carol Jones's avatar

Desperation because their MSM gig is not getting the prominence, stroking or funding it was. That all belongs to social media. So they hire pip-squeaks who talk first, research/study last-- cause it gets them "trending" on s. media or they are being talked about. Because the NYT is not being talked about as path breaking investigative journalism.

They can't become People magazine -- that market is full, so what market do they find their relevance in? How do you compete vs. Glenn, Max Blumenthal, Matt Taibbi, Aaron Mate etc.? They can't even with all their resources. The problem for them is their news gathering structure , it is ancient and obsolete-- so they struggle and hire Lorenz.

Katisha's avatar

Heard an explanation that it wont work during a pandemic, as small businesses are already struggling. But let's face it, that's weak tea. No one in the antigovernment has cared about small businesses since March 2020.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

Don't worry, their big business friends are going to buy up all the market share for peanuts on the dollar because only big $ business could really weather 1+ year of restricted business. We saw this in CA a decade ago after CA Medicaid reduced payments by 10%. https://lao.ca.gov/Recommendations/Details/294

SimulationCommander's avatar

And they will buy up the rubble with all that newly printed cash.

There's a reason that BTC is skyrocketing.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

BTC is skyrocketing because the big finance hubs can make huge margins manipulating it's value just like they did with GameStop. Its one of the few areas of wild west investing still left.

Katisha's avatar

Uni government meant to say.

Art's avatar

And 15 is spit-in-your-eye too low; as Elizabeth Warren pointed out in the 2016 cycle - I think her comment was actually in 2015 - that there are two very different but very valid ways to look at what the Minimum Wage _should_be,_ one based on it having been tied to "the rate of inflation" at inception, or to "the Consumer Price Index" instead, and in both cases, the rate would have been over $24/hour at the time she spoke.

$15 is a joke.

And as for raising it during the pandemic, OK, fine, I can understand that, so you simply tweak the legislation so it reads that it applies to all "large" businesses immediately and to "small" businesses "as soon as the pandemic ends." ...BTW, last time I checked, "small business" was defined as those that employ less than 500 people. Oh, and another BTW, that lets ULTRA-RICH holding companies claim all sorts of tax advantages because they're "small businesses" even though they have gross receipts in the billions of dollars.

Roland's avatar

Do you really think that the pandemic will ever be declared over? Don’t be naive. Once they’ve got the “low lives” by short hairs they’ll never let go. Do as your told !!!!! It’s a pandemic. Never let a good crises go to waste.

Art's avatar

Yes, I do, the public will demand it. You can be sure. What it takes is for the majority of hospitals to have insufficient quantities of Covid-19 patients to be considered even half full and a decreasing rate of infection. When that happens, we'll have broken the back of the pandemic and it will be "mop-up-crew" time to finish the job off.

A vital key is vaccination. The Sooner The Better.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

Now you are a medical pandemic expert? Or did you just listen to the good DNC and media's coverage of this planted, man-made virus that shockingly ended the best economy the US had ever had just in time for an election!

Pawsative's avatar

The illegal aliens where I live demand $25 an hour for yard work and housecleaning. More than most Americans are making.

Cathy Carron's avatar

Yup - in NW CT as well - and they don’t want more coming over the border because they don’t want the competition

Lightwing's avatar

$30/hour where I live.

Art's avatar

Sounds to me those "Americans" you're talking about should be demanding more, too. Perhaps they're just to servile?

"Americans" used to stand up for themselves, join unions, have solidarity between their unions and work for a better life for all of us. While you can still find such people, their numbers are pitifully low at present. How about we reawaken the Union spirit? Too communistic for you?

Phisto Sobanii's avatar

The best idea I've had so far for any kind of reawakening is unplug.

Not from tech or the internet, per se, but the mainstream circus. I'll admit, it's a mountain of a job. But thankfully, our minds are a pickaxe.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 9, 2021
Comment deleted
David Pare's avatar

That inflation-adjustment is an interesting concept. The $7.25 rate was set in 2009, as per: https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/minimum-wage/history/chart Inflation since then per CPIAUCSL is 21%. (about 2% per year). So that's just $8.84; where did Warren get $24? Still, I didn't realize it hadn't been raised since 2009. That's a long time with no raise. Seems like Biden could have done *something* for workers. Lots of people got goodies in that Big Stimulus Bill.

Art's avatar

You're apparently forgetting the compunding effect. And, you're apparently unaware of the HUGE inflation of the mid 1970s that, of course, gave the excuses to get rid of heavy taxation on the ultra-rich.

As for where Warren got it, do a web search, but she did explain it at the time. I'm sure you'll find it and, BTW, it's not particularly hard to do the analysis yourself.

David Pare's avatar

Perhaps you can tell me where I went wrong: I brought up the timeseries CPIAUCSL from fred. Here: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CPIAUCSL The value of this series in July 2009 was 214.726. The value today is 261.775. That's a 21.9% increase. Does this calculation seem right to you? If so, 21.9% times $7.25 is $1.59. What am I missing?

Katisha's avatar

And these large companies pay so little that many of their employees are eligible for food stamps and Medicaid. So the oligarchs are screwing their employees and the taxpayers!

Pel's avatar

Here you are actually on something. Yes, large companies get to squeeze their workers on pay. How? By using their naturally superior negotiating power. The only cure? More smaller companies. How? By making it easier and less burdensome to run a small company. That is, cut regulations, unify taxation, do not create artificial contractual obligations for employers; large companies thrive on regulations, small busines owners are strained enough already, to the point of extinction, they cannot afford notorious "your lawyer" (as if they needed only one these days). That is, Trump should have been your natural choice; but you refused to act on it. Now relax and enjoy the rule of large companies and lawyers -- your fought hard for it after all. And you won!

Art's avatar

If I had the ability to make law, I'd have a law that says that any corporation who has any full time employee who is eligible for public assistance just to pay their ordinary bills should be assessed 15% of their gross income for that year, to be taken FIRST from the leadership of the company's compensation, reducing it down to the same as whoever works for that company who was so eligible for public assistance.

That ought to solve it. ... Well, and also that they can't just make people not full-time to screw them that way...

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

Minimum wage isn't called "minimum" for no reason. Its the minimum you can live on.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

What evidence would you give of someone providing more than a $15 hour minimum wage and it being successful? Do you not think the capitalist corporations running the world just turn around and pass that cost off down the line? You think they just take the hit to their ROI and be like oh yeah fuck it lets just give our workers a bigger share of the pie? LOL!!!!

What about the workers who grabbed too much when they had all the power with their private sector unions? How has that worked out in the global economy the DNC and RNC elite support? How come Carter didn't meet with the Steel industry when they collapsed? Let me guess... "he wasn't left". How come Bill Clinton passed NAFTA over his own party's objections? Let me guess...."he wasn't left"?

Art's avatar

That's right, Bill Clinton wasn't and isn't left. NOW you're starting to catch on; Clinton is neo-liberal.

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

Another post responding to me, saying a DNC president "wasn't left" and yet another post without you pointing at someone you think is. Say something substantive. Put your name behind your belief. Give us a candidate that you, Lord Gatekeeper of the labeling of Left Politicians think is truly left.

Lightwing's avatar

With Ratings Down, the Networks Hunt for a Trump Replacement: https://taibbi.substack.com/p/without-trump-is-a-depression-in

Trump saved the cable news business once. Without him, things are looking bleak again. Who will they find to feed the outrage machine?

Wazoomann's avatar

I thought the same. Now I realize....you can just keep going. After the election, we have the impeachment. Blaming previous administration for CV19 rollout, white nationalism, fascism that must be squelched with stringent authoritarianism. All these narrative need Orange Man Bad; like soup needs salt to taste better. I'm sure there will be more. Guaranteed. Orange Man Bad has a long runway. (for reference, see, Russia, Hillary's emails, FBI Comey saga, etc. etc.)

THEKILLERWHALE's avatar

God damn, you came back dropping bombs!

NoSuchCommentator's avatar

It is understandable that reporters at the NYT are sensitive about certain words. Mr. Andreessen may not have used the R word, but he could have used it at any moment. Ms. Lorenz should not have to live in continual fear and it is arguably worse dealing with the suspense of when Mr. Andreessen will drop the R word than if he had actually uttered it. Free speech does not give you the right to terrorize others with all the things you might potentially say.

Unfortunately, those who have the privilege not to work for the NYT probably will never understand this degree of suffering.

Lightwing's avatar

ROFLMAO! Wow. You win this board and the internet!! Good stuff...

bahhummingbug IV substack's avatar

Sticks and stones may break my bones, but the R word will never hurt me.

NoSuchCommentator's avatar

New York Times reporters (apologies for using the R word) are more sensitive than you.

bahhummingbug IV substack's avatar

That's impossible. .. I can sense the slightest human suffering.

*aside ~ it's a little late, but this impeachment is much better than the last impeachment.

NoSuchCommentator's avatar

Third impeachment will be the charm.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 8, 2021
Comment deleted
NoSuchCommentator's avatar

All words are offensive to someone. Using first letters only is best.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 10, 2021
Comment deleted
NoSuchCommentator's avatar

True - words are a waste. De-platform everybody!

Gary Kartchner's avatar

Great article! Thanks Glenn.

Loved the below...

“They have insufficient talent or skill, and even less desire, to take on real power centers: the military-industrial complex, the CIA and FBI, the clandestine security state, Wall Street, Silicon Valley monopolies, the corrupted and lying corporate media outlets they serve.”

Robert Dodge's avatar

Don’t forget their core insufficiency: character. What they have in sufficient supply to overcome all those insufficiencies is ignorance and a breathtaking level of naivety.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 7, 2021
Comment deleted
Lightwing's avatar

I guessed Oscar Wilde but it's George Burns. Nice.

Bernadene Zennie's avatar

K Well Glenn I am a great grandma living on SS and a small nurse's pension having become radicalized about the time the VN war was over and realized all the lies, and never looked back...not once, but have been more and less active over the years d/t work, kids, late higher education, divorce, etc etc. so always have had limited ability to give $ but not energy or desire for the truth. But d/t this column, have subscribed now with a v. small monthly stipend I could afford, in this so critical time. I so wish it were more, hopefully one day it will be more. If not for you, Chris Hedges, Noam, Lee Camp, and your moral and intellectual cohorts I wouldn't know jack shit. You are in my thoughts and prayers. Stay safe, keep the faith and stay strong. We are here for you.

Jim M's avatar

I'm 62. And when I was a kid, up until I was 15 and they stopped the draft, I KNEW I was going to Viet Nam. All the 'big kids' in my working neighborhood went. They stopped the draft when I was 15 and whoa the relief I felt. B/c I was also convinced I would die over there.

I was raised Catholic, and as a child I was an altar boy. 67-71 there was some kind of build up, and we served at funeral masses during school hours. It was sweet to get out of class...

Until the boys started coming home in boxes. Half a century later, I can still see the destroyed familes at those funerals. What a horrid time.

Jen Koenig's avatar

I've always thought that we should draft the upper classes to war first. So Biden wants to bomb Syria? OK, well, we'll enlist Harvard and Yale to do so. Hunter goes as well. Also Pelosi's grandkids. Girls too. On the front line! Wouldn't want to be sexist. I am convinced this would end American imperialism overnight.

Art's avatar

Yes, and it's a better solution than simply ending the draft.

Jen Koenig's avatar

I'm in favor of bringing it back. Upper classes first.

Mack B's avatar

Let me share with you something of a similar nature. I am 76 years old and a graduate of Tulane. For the past year I have become alarmed at the woke course Tulane has taken. From a disproportionate number of liberal versus conservative professors, to supporting BLM ( who by the 3 founders own admission "we are trained Marxists"), to a english professor ( yes ENGLISH) starting a course called "Feminism after Trumplandia", to a professor telling a story of a student who thought he was a student and suggested "You should try out for the baseball team" saying that such comment was a"microaggression", to mandating Critical Race Theory as a required course for freshmen. All of this nonsense was too much for me. So I wrote many a dozen emails over time. At least 3 to the President of Tulane, one to the english professor,and emails to the Dean of the English Dept and well a Deans of other schools at Tulane, the Provost, and even the President of the Tulane Alumni Association. How many responded to my concerns ? None. A big fat 0. I believe that Tulane believes if they just ignore I will go away. But I have news for them. The war is long. I'm not giving up until I have a public say on this far left course my beloved alma mater is taking. I have no problem with people who are liberal. But its not right for all thought, if not liberal, to be shut out. Tulane needs to at least hear and be tolerant of a different view.

DividedUpWorld's avatar

College, a dead useless concept.

Mack B's avatar

thank you for taking the time to read what I wrote

Jim M's avatar

Not at all. I'm happy I went, and my kids did too. Yeah, yeah; grievance studies are a rip off for sure, but any other dept will teach you critical thinking skills.

Jim M's avatar

You're aware of Peterson, Lindsay, and Weinstien's experiences I assume? If not, just google those names w/ CRT on them.

People are waking up, man. This shit from the Frankfurt school of thought has been going on for generations. It's taken over the NYT (I'll be cancelling my sub for the final time today) and pretty much the majority of Establishment higher ed (Ivy League and the 2nd tiers). It ain't good. I believe we're witnessing a Cultural Revolution in real time.

judd's avatar

if you read abt the history of NYT, they have always been morally bankrupt, covering for Hitler and Stalin at different points in time. Lovely.

Cathy Carron's avatar

We canceled our NYTimes sub this week as well. No need to support crazy talk.

Jim M's avatar

It used to be you were informed; even if you didn't agree. Now...I just feel that I'm being propagandized to the point of brainwashed.

Mack B's avatar

Thank you so much for taking the time to read what I wrote. I will take your advice and google those names. Take care, be safe !

Jim M's avatar

It's a rabbit hole, Mack. For me, it started w/ this video: https://www.tvo.org/video/genders-rights-and-freedom-of-speech

Tony Bombassolo's avatar

Interesting, do you donate as an alumni? Call your graduation year class alumni rep and give him/her the business.

Cathy Carron's avatar

We stopped donating to Smith, Wellesley, Harvard, Yale - they have all been corrupted with ‘wokeness’.

Mack B's avatar

I use to donate but not anymore.......I went to Tulane on a football scholarship and still communicate with many of my old teammates. They are helping me brainstorm. Thanks so much for reading what I wrote

Anna Sneddon's avatar

Glenn on Feb 3 "...take this week off ... will be back on Monday, February 8". Well Glenn, at least you tried 😉 Hope you enjoyed your 4 day vacay. 🍹

Cathy Carron's avatar

Glenn is describing a form of mass psychosis amongst privileged leftist elites, many of whom are employed by the old, decayed & very faded 'Grey Lady', The New York Times. We just stopped our FOUR decades long run of a subscription. Don't support this intellectual malfeasance.

The Other Jackie's avatar

I just cancelled my four decade long subscription also.

Jo Gregg's avatar

Decades ago, we started out with a noble idea, equality for all regardless of skin color, ethnicity, or sex. Now we've descended into an absurd state where people are destroyed for uttering a word from the (growing) collection determined by the mob to be offensive. Meanwhile, mob members make ludicrous claims about their "pain and suffering" from having to hear these particular words. We've become a parody and the antithesis of serious people solving serious problems.

Jim Trageser's avatar

Great stuff. But I wouldn't call the Stasi hall-monitors "journalists." You are a journalist. These two-bit lowlife bullies are not journalists. They are media whores, and should be so described.

Carol Jones's avatar

Apparatchiks-- enablers of the state